The fundamentals of natural sound travel uniformly in all directions – a piano, for example,
distributes sound throughout a room.
Our hearing favors speakers that reproduce sound in the same way.
Wide-dispersion speakers sound more real because they too fill the room.
Limited-dispersion speakers seem less realistic because they beam, or
project sound into only one area.
Wide dispersion throughout a speaker’s bandwidth is difficult to achieve.
Most high-frequency and bass/midrange drive units have good dispersion
at the lower limits of their frequency range, but they naturally start to beam
as they reach their upper-frequency limits. With high-performance high-frequency
drivers beaming occurs beyond audibility. Beaming from midrange drivers, however,
occurs within the audible range. Speakers with beaming problems will not sound the
same in all areas of a room. They may sound balanced in one area, but nasal, dull, or
even harsh and shrill in other areas.
Midrange beaming can be reduced by lowering the crossover frequency.
The high-frequency driver’s lower range will then provide wider dispersion
and the bass/midrange driver’s output can be rolled off before its dispersion narrows.
This is an effective approach but requires the use of a high-frequency drivers
that can handle the vast amounts of power it takes to reproduce these frequencies.
This driver must be very robust and as a consequence, will be expensive to produce.
Many speaker companies are unwilling to incur the cost of building high-power
high-frequency drivers, thus not all speakers have uniformly wide dispersion.
A crossover is a network of electrical devices that divides the audio
signal into separate frequency bands and directs them to the individual
speaker drivers. The frequency at which it does this is called the crossover
frequency, or crossover point.
Figure 1
In order to protect a delicate high-frequency driver from damage,
many speaker companies will set their crossovers quite high. Unfortunately,
this encourages midrange beaming
Figure 2
Speakers with more robust high-frequency drivers and lower crossover points do not suffer from beaming problems – they disperse sound uniformly and widely